Top Hat Retirement: Alternatives to Top Hat for Attendance and Student Engagement

Body

Description 

Ohio University will retire Top Hat when the contract ends in January of 2027. Top Hat’s most common uses were for polling and attendance. This article outlines recommended alternatives that you can use to support your instructional goals for these cases. 

  • OIT Instructional Technologists are available to help you evaluate tools that support your teaching strategies. Schedule a consultation.  
  • Users can continue contacting Top Hat Support for assistance until January 30th, 2027.

Environment

Canvas LMS, Mac, PC, web browser 

Solution: Recommended Alternatives by Teaching Need 

Instructors use a range of approaches to track attendance, encourage participation, and support secure assessments depending on course modality, class size, instructional goals, and technology preferences. Canvas and its related tools support multiple approaches, from simple in‑person roll taking to flexible online check‑ins, live polling, and high‑stakes exam proctoring.

The options below are grouped by primary use case and highlight tool capabilities and what type of course it may fit best. No single tool fits every scenario; instead, instructors are encouraged to select the approach that best aligns with how attendance, participation, or exam security is defined in their course. The table that follows summarizes each option, when it works best, and key considerations to help guide that choice.

Consider consulting with an instructional technologist to further explore which tool best fits your instructional goals. If you wish to pursue an alternative tool not supported currently by OIT, please submit a Technology Review to ensure the tool meets accessibility, security, and other essential considerations before using it for instructional activities. 

For instructors leveraging Top Hat's publisher content, we encourage you to explore the variety of resources available through University Libraries or to review options through the Inclusive Access - Digital Course Materials program. You can also develop and share your own content in your courses using Canvas's PagesFiles, and Modules capabilities.


1. Attendance Tracking - Comparison Table

Tool

What It Does (Including Instructor Task) 

Best For 

Canvas Attendance 

(Roll Call)

Tracks Present/Late/Absent each class session. Instructor task: enable Roll Call, open the tool each session, manually mark attendance. 

Gradebook Sync: Automatic

Setup Effort: Low

In-person, small to medium class size

Canvas Quiz 

 

Students complete a short quiz as their attendance marker. Instructor task: create a quiz (per session or weekly), set availability/password, review auto‑grading.

Gradebook Sync: Automatic

Setup Effort: Medium

In‑person, online, asynchronous, large enrollment 

Canvas Discussion 

 

Students post a reply to confirm presence/participation. Instructor task: create discussion, set deadlines, grade or apply rubric. 

Gradebook Sync: Automatic

Setup Effort: Medium

Asynchronous; participation focus over attendance focus
Canvas New Analytics 

Provides interactive graphs and tables so instructors can track student grades, submission status, weekly course activity, and individual student participation. Can also be used as a supplemental indicator of online activity (not a record of attendance). Students can view data about their course grades, weekly online activity, and Inbox communication. 

Gradebook Sync: None

Setup Effort: Low

Online attendance

Microsoft Forms Quiz 

via Microsoft Education Canvas integration

Students complete a Form embedded in Canvas as an attendance check. Instructor task: create Form, attach to Canvas via assignment, confirm grade passback, set deadlines.

Gradebook Sync: Automatic (when configured)

Setup Effort: Medium

Online, hybrid, Microsoft ‑centric content
Qualtrics Survey

Students submit a simple survey to confirm attendance. Instructor task: create survey, share link, manually verify responses and enter grades if needed. 

Gradebook Sync: None

Setup Effort: Medium-High

Research or custom needs 

2. Live Polling & Real‑Time Engagement — Comparison Table 

Tool

What It Does (Including Instructor Task) 

Best For 

Canvas Discussions 

Students reply to a prompt for real‑time or windowed engagement. Instructor task: create discussion, set expectations, grade or apply rubric.

Gradebook Sync: Automatic

Real‑Time Results: Yes (different format than polling)

Setup Effort: Low

Asynchronous; reflection activities 

Microsoft Teams Polls 

via Microsoft Education Canvas integration

Launch live, in‑meeting polls during Teams sessions. Instructor task: create polls before/during meeting, run them, export results for grading.

Gradebook Sync: None (manual import)

Real‑Time Results: Yes 

Setup Effort: Low-Medium

Synchronous online or hybrid 

Microsoft Forms Quiz 

via Microsoft Education Canvas integration

Short quiz for participation or comprehension checks. Instructor task: create Form, attach to Canvas assignment, configure grading.

Gradebook Sync: Automatic (with LTI)

Real‑Time Results: Near real-time updates

Setup Effort: Medium

Any modality

Microsoft Forms

standalone tool

Create a variety of quiz questions with the option for students to reply via a personal device after scanning a QR code. Display results after students respond to prompt discussion or check for understanding.

Gradebook Sync: None (manual import)

Real‑Time Results: Near real-time updates

Setup Effort: Low-Medium

Synchronous online or in-person. Situations where anonymous polling is desired. 
Qualtrics Survey 

Structured survey for engagement or feedback. Instructor task: create survey, share link, manually review/grade. 

Gradebook Sync: None

Real‑Time Results: No

Setup Effort: Medium-High

Asynchronous or complex logic needs 

3. Proctoring-Related Software Resources — Comparison Table 

Tool

What It Does (Including Instructor Task) 

Best For 

Respondus LockDown Browser 

Secures online exams by preventing students from accessing other websites, applications, or system functions like copy/paste, screen capture, or printing while a test is in progress. Instructor task: Enable the Respondus LockDown browser option in an exam in Canvas. 

Gradebook Sync: Automatic

Real‑Time Results: Yes

Setup Effort: Low

Synchronous, hybrid, online, 

Large enrollment courses

Proctortrack                                      

Secures online exams by combining browser lockdown with identity verification and continuous monitoring via webcam, microphone, screen capture, and room scans. 

 Instructor task: setup an onborading exam and an online proctored exam in Proctortrack. 

Gradebook Sync: Automatic

Real‑Time Results: Yes

Setup Effort: Medium (and has additional cost for use)

High-stakes online exams

Time-Saving Tips for Instructors

Here are actionable strategies instructors can use regardless of which tools they choose. 

General Efficiency Tips 

  • Reuse content week‑to‑week. Duplicate quizzes, discussions, and assignments instead of creating from scratch. 

  • Create weekly attendance/participation bundles. Instead of one quiz per class session, use one weekly quiz with multiple prompts. 

  • Use auto‑grading wherever possible. Canvas Quizzes and Microsoft Forms both support auto‑scoring and instant recording. 

  • Use clear, consistent naming conventions. Example: “Week 3 — Attendance Check” or “Participation Quiz — Module 5.” 

Large Enrollment Tips

  • Use question banks or item pools to randomize attendance/password questions. 

  • Apply rubrics on discussions to speed up grading. 

  • Export poll/quiz data to Excel for faster bulk processing (e.g., Teams Polls). 

  • Use bulk grade import in Canvas to avoid entering scores one by one. 

In-Person Tips: Attendance Taking

  • For quizzes or Forms, display a one‑time code in class to prevent remote submissions. 

  • Use short availability windows ("open for 10 minutes") to reduce academic integrity issues. 

Online Synchronous Tips 

  • Schedule recurring polls in Teams so they’re ready before class. 

  • Auto‑open quizzes at the start of a meeting using Canvas' availability settings. 

Asynchronous Teaching Tips 

  • Allow weekly windows for attendance check‑ins. 

  • Use graded discussions with rubrics to minimize individual comment review time. 

Microsoft 365‑Centric Tips 

  • Store recurring Forms in a Forms group to reuse templates across semesters. 

  • Use Excel exports to batch review, then bring grades into Canvas in one upload. 

Get Help From Canvas

  • Get 24-hours/7-days a week Canvas support   

  • Dial the Canvas Support Hotline number located under "Get Help" in the Canvas Global Navigation Menu  

  • Contact OIT at 740-593-1222 for questions related to logging in, test courses/manually created courses, or tools that connect to Canvas.

Get Help from OIT

Additional Resources  

Accessibility

Ohio University strives to make its digital resources and services accessible to all visitors, including those with disabilities who may also be using assistive technology. If special steps are necessary in order to improve the accessibility of experiences for end-users, those steps must be taken.  
 
If you experience a barrier that affects your ability to access OHIO websites, videos, online forums, documents, or other information technology, please let us know.  
For further information about OHIO's digital accessibility resources, see:  

Security

The Ohio University Information Security Office strives to educate and empower the University community to appropriately manage risks and protect OHIO’s information and systems. This effort is facilitated through policies, standards, and information security risk management program, as well as other tools and guidance that are provided to the University community. This modern approach creates a safe computing environment in which the University community can teach, learn, and conduct research.  

For additional information about OHIO’s security resources, see:  

 

 

Details

Details

Article ID: 1614
Created
Fri 4/17/26 2:41 PM
Modified
Tue 5/5/26 6:59 AM